Soldering iron test and price comparison: soldering iron, gas soldering iron and battery soldering iron in

Soldering iron, gas soldering iron and battery soldering iron in the do-it-yourself test

Soldering iron test and price comparison: soldering iron, gas soldering iron and battery soldering iron in: test

Soldering irons are irreplaceable for electrical work in the home improvement sector. When a solder joint comes loose Wire breaks or you do electronic tinkering loves a good soldering iron is essential.

Important criteria are the heat-up time and the possible temperature settings, However, only soft soldering is possible with the commercially available copper soldering tips.

We have tested for you different soldering irons of different price ranges and purposes: from cheap, small soldering iron on the digital high-tech soldering station Much can be used to melt the connecting tin.

Soldering and soldering iron: worth knowing for DIY and hobby electronics

Soldering is known for Jewelery making for over 5000 yearsBut only in the electronic age has it received groundbreaking meaning.

The permanent, electric conductive connection of two components by means of a soft solder is indispensable from any hobby cellar.

So as varied as the possible uses of the soldering process are, so are the demands on the used soldering device and the solder:

We are dealing here exclusively with devices for soft solder connections as they are common in the hobby area. The technique of brazing, defined as a soldering process from a temperature of 450° C, is rather rare in the hobby field and is for example for the Connection of heating pipes used, It requires special knowledge and solders.

Basically, one should observe some safety rules when soldering: Evaporative Solder is unhealthy, adequate ventilation should of course his.

Likewise, solder, especially beginners, easy splash: A stable and heat-resistant surface and protective goggles should be just as natural.

Soldering Iron Test Candidates at a Glance

All test candidates at a glance: From simple Electric soldering iron via the gas alternative up to the digital soldering station.

Test table

Simple soldering ironERSA MultitipFERM SGM-1006Soldering gun BT-SG 100Weller battery soldering ironMcVoice LS-1000
price8,99 €42,99 €28,98 €11,04 €24,04 €52,45 €
power30 W15Wgas operation100W8 - 11 wattsAdjustable
tip (Supplied)pencilpencilvariousLötwendelpencilpencil

Simple soldering iron: The "solder economy class" in the test

Soldering iron test and price comparison: soldering iron, gas soldering iron and battery soldering iron in: price

Simple soldering iron

Anyone who solves this problem can do little wrong, but can not expect too much: with one cheap standard soldering iron, most home improvement are actually relatively well served - if you do not solder too often and not too filigree connections.

The device presented here offers no surprises: It lies well in the hand, only the thick, slightly tending to twisting connection cable spoils the Lötgenuss a little.

The heating time is relatively long, the Power with 30 watts not excessive sized. If you solder only occasionally, you will still be well served with the device - but you should not tackle boards here.

The Soldering tip is often the biggest weak point No-name offers: Fast it tends to become dirty, causing the soldering iron to slowly but surely become unusable. Replacement soldering tips are not always standard in this price range, they also have to fit the device.

Simple soldering iron: pros and cons

Per

  • cheap price
  • simple handling
  • Fits comfortably in your hand
  • LED lighting (on this model)

contra

  • Connection cable likes to twist
  • moderate quality of the soldering tips
  • Not suitable for continuous use, blanks and filigree work

ERSA 1457108 Multitip 15W

Soldering iron test and price comparison: soldering iron, gas soldering iron and battery soldering iron in: comparison

ERSA Multitip

From the expert for connoisseurs: This soldering iron is in relevant Internet forums and Trade journals recommended again and again as a casual and starter device; not entirely wrong.

With a good soldering performance and a clean result also and especially in fine soldering The ERSA proposes cheap models by far, the device also looks high-quality and works well in the hand.

The standard tip of the soldering iron is pencil sharpened and is sufficient due to the quite low heat output of only 15 watts aOnly for smaller soldering work with leaded solder, but this is not very healthy.

Nevertheless, the ERSA does its job well and is for casual solder with skillful hands absolutely recommendable.

ERSA 1457108 Multitip 15W: Pros and Cons

Per

  • quite cheap
  • simple handling
  • well processed
  • suitable for filigree work

contra

  • low heat output
  • thin soldering tip restricts applications

Gas soldering iron Ferm SGM1006

Soldering iron test and price comparison: soldering iron, gas soldering iron and battery soldering iron in: price

FERM SGM-1006

Similar to the kitchen stove, there is also an alternative to gas with soldering iron: with one Gas soldering iron is the heat right there if you need them, he will operate with a simple lighter gas.

The gas flame creates a adjustable temperature from 400 to 500° C, fast and to the point.

However, gas soldering irons are not only suitable for soldering: You can also plastic welding and cutting with them, for these cases has the FERM SGM1006 a comprehensive accessory packaget in the luggage.

Due to the high achievable temperatures could even be brazed with the FERMbut we have not tested this in practice.

The aspect of universal and independent usability, the extensive accessories as well as the reasonably priced price make the FERM gas soldering iron but already in the run-up to the co-favorites.

Ferm SGM1006: Pros and Cons

Per

  • quick heat to the point
  • universally and independently applicable
  • extensive accessories
  • is operated with cheap lighter gas
  • powerful

contra

  • no gas, no soldering
  • The device gets really hot
  • Not suitable for continuous use, blanks and filigree work

Soldering gun Einhell BT-SG 100

Soldering iron test and price comparison: soldering iron, gas soldering iron and battery soldering iron in: comparison

Soldering gun BT-SG 100

A soldering gun not only looks different than a soldering iron, it also works differently: When Soldering iron is die The current is not flowing through the tip, but with a soldering gun beautiful.

To prevent sparks and electric shock, the electricity must pass through the outside line with very low voltage flowbut still be very strong.

The resulting thick lead wires thus require a different design; in the "piston" of the gun is therefore a Transformer integrated, which has the necessary voltage and power provides.

soldering guns provide quick heating to the point, a handle on the "trigger" heats the wire loop in seconds. The clear disadvantage of a soldering gun, in addition to its inherent "shapelessness" and its weight, their only gross motoric applicability: Smaller soldering or even boards remain better with the soldering gun untouched.

On the other hand, who would like to tin or flexible cables (speaker cable or similar) or Cutting plastic ropes and want to soil is correct with a soldering gun.

Soldering guns are not suitable for continuous operation; The pistol heats up and can be destroyed. This also applies when cutting hard foam and other thermoplastics. With 100 watts, the power consumption of the soldering gun is considerably higher than that of a soldering iron, correspondingly more force flows through the helix.

Soldering Gun Einhell BT-SG 100: Pro and Contra

Per

  • fast heating
  • also suitable for hard foam and thermoplastics

contra

  • chunky
  • not suitable for continuous use, blanks and filigree work
  • not a "soldering iron" in the classical sense

Battery soldering iron from Weller

Soldering iron test and price comparison: soldering iron, gas soldering iron and battery soldering iron in: comparison

Weller battery soldering iron

Without plug, without gas: The battery soldering iron from Weller sounds at first glance for a less convincing solution.

Out four standard 1.5 volt batteries should he Soldering iron develop 11 watts of power; For big jumps and long missions these values ​​are certainly not enough.

Nevertheless, the device convinces at second glance: It actually workseven if the battery charge neither for long-range soldering rich for lead-free solder tinst.

The Heating up phase is extremely short, only 10 seconds. A disadvantage of the operation, however, is that the power button must be kept pressed during the entire soldering process; this is a bit unwieldy. Also is the Battery power naturally exhausted pretty quickly, Replacement batteries or rechargeable batteries are a must.

Battery soldering iron from Weller: Pro and Contra

Per

  • regardless of the power supply
  • practical case
  • surprisingly short heating time

contra

  • low power through battery operation
  • short battery life
  • fumbling operation

Soldering station Mc Voice LS-1000

Soldering iron test and price comparison: soldering iron, gas soldering iron and battery soldering iron in: test

McVoice LS-1000

Soldering stations are for the ambitious amateur hunter often the means of choice: Significantly more expensive than conventional soldering irons, they usually offer a handy stand, a digital preselection of the soldering temperature, often with Storage locations as well as a soldering sponge and usually good soldering iron with good soldering tips.

The "professional soldering station" McVoice LS1000 we tested offers a lot for little money: Three pre-selectable fixed temperatures, a temperature setting to 1° C and a potential-free soldering tip, which protects sensitive electronics during soldering. Useful is also the standby function, which keeps the soldering iron at temperature for short interruptions.

In terms of handling, the soldering station does not ultimately differ from the two soldering iron in the test; except that Temperature adapted to different fluxest can be.

Here is a clear advantage of the station. Even with sensitive components, For example, ICs or PC components helps the potential-free soldering tip continue. All in all, a good device with all the advantages at a fair price - if you need a soldering station.

Soldering station McVoice LS-1000: Pros and Cons

Per

  • perfect tuning to different solders
  • passably processed
  • easy to read display
  • good soldering performance

contra

  • nothing - except the price

Soldering iron test: comparison winner

Soldering iron test and price comparison: soldering iron, gas soldering iron and battery soldering iron in: soldering

Purchase recommendation: Digital soldering station McVoice LS-1000

Our comparison winner is the soldering station McVoice LS-1000.This mainly has to do with the good equipment, the clean soldering result and the practical handling.

Although the station is an absolute bargain with approx. 50 €, it convinces through its workmanship and quality and is in no way inferior to its competitors except in design and perhaps in the housing finish.

However, if you rarely and little solder, a normal soldering iron is enough: Here we recommend the ERSA Multitip: A little cheaper, with interchangeable tips and Made in Germany. Again, you can not go wrong.

Soldering Iron: Value for money winner

Soldering iron test and price comparison: soldering iron, gas soldering iron and battery soldering iron in: soldering

Value for money: The simple NoName soldering iron

Our price / performance winner is, as expected, the simple soldering iron. For the occasional to lesser looter anyway the first choice, he reliably smelt most solders and is usually sufficient for work in the home improvement sector completely.

Demanding electronic craftsmen may be bothered by the somewhat crude appearance of the piston, the casual craftsman, however, enjoys the acceptable quality of the soldering result and the favorable complete exchange: If you accidentally burn the cord through you can get a new soldering iron for an unbeatable price.

Correct desoldering: How to solve solder joints professionally

Soldering iron test and price comparison: soldering iron, gas soldering iron and battery soldering iron in: comparison

LS20 - Entlötlitze

There has been much talk in this test of soldering - but little on desoldering. This is included repairs at least as important as the new one Production of a solid solder joint.

The easiest way to do it is with one Braid Desoldering: This consists of many small copper wires, which according to the capillary principle, the solder from the solder joint after the Aspirate and absorb melting.

Entlötlitze is of course a consumable material; as a result of rising copper prices, it is too not very cheap.

Soldering iron test and price comparison: soldering iron, gas soldering iron and battery soldering iron in: iron

Lotsaugpumpe Fixpoint LSP 100 Q

As an alternative without consumption costs with similarly good results, therefore, recommends the Using a desoldering pump.

These sucks the solder away from the solder joint with negative pressure and leaves a clean desoldered board - if you have the right device.

Guns work either mechanically or, especially in a professional environment, with air pressure or electric drive.

Select solder and solder correctly

Soldering iron test and price comparison: soldering iron, gas soldering iron and battery soldering iron in: soldering

solder

The colloquial "solder" is only part of the truth: For the different purposes There are many soldering different solders with specific properties.

The single solders are over Abbreviations distinguishedto give initiates information about the ingredients.

In the hobby area, lead in the Lot is still the rule; the Melting properties are excellent, you only need low temperatures and the solder joint is permanent.

There Bleilot, however, is harmful to health, its use in newer electrical appliances is prohibited - in the hobby area, however, the supply is still ensured.

The different solders at a glance:

short nameingredientsapplicationmelting point
PbSn4060% lead, 40% tinthin sheet236° C
Sn60Pb60% tin, 40% leadTinning ("Radiolot")183° C
Sn50PbCu

50% tin, 49% lead, 1% copper

Electrical appliances190° C
Sn60PbAg60% tin, 36% lead, 4% copperelectronics180° C

Similar sites

  • SOS accessories - online store in the test
  • Home improvement tests: tools & household products in the test and comparison
  • Hot glue gun test and price comparison
  • High pressure cleaner test and price comparison
  • Brushcutters Test: Petrol brushcutters in comparison
  • Flexible Garden Hose Test: FITT YOYO
  • Electric lawnmower test and price comparison
  • Polishing machines test: polish properly
  • Hardware Market Test: The winners
  • Surveillance Camera Test: Blaupunkt VIO series
  • Tool case Test: Tool boxes for your tools
  • SmartHome Test - home automation by innogy in the test
  • Third hand
  • soldering iron
  • soldering Station

Video Board: USB soldering iron test and teardown with schematic.