Vise comparison 2018

Purchase advice on the vise comparison or test 2018

  • Vices clamp workpieces with high force. They are a good helper when, for example, drilling precisely into a pipe.
  • How hard the vise compresses is precisely adjusted with a crank.
  • Vices are so strong and robust that they even bend metal. Some are also suitable for forging.

Vise comparison 2018: 2018

1. The Vise: A faithful companion for many years

Vise comparison 2018: comparison

Holds reliably while you are busy with other things.

In a good workshop, a vice always belongs on the workbench. In general, you only buy a vise once, because this tool is extremely robust and durable.

Securely bolted to the workbench, a vise holds workpieces while you tackle them with a saw, rasp or drill. See the vise as your perfect home improvement wizard: He is always there, holds on, does not give in and is nevertheless precise.


Vise comparison 2018: vice

The vise flail rotates the spindle.

Use a rotary lever to operate the vise. This so-called vise flail is in the vise spindle. In turn, the vise jaws rest on this spindle. Turn the lever and at the same time turn the spindle, The spindle either brings the jaws together or apart, depending on which direction you turn the lever.

What the vise can do

The vise jaws hold not only objects, but the vise can deform with them and factory parts, so crush. This is handy when working with sheets. The vise never pushes on its own, This means that the jaws remain in the position in which they were brought.

For example, screw clamps are different. These sit with the work part with tension. As a result, some screw clamps press the object to be clamped ever further together. The jaws of a vice, however, remain in their position, This allows him to hold much more precise than a screw clamp.

Advantages and disadvantages of a vice compared to a screw clamp:

  • keeps his jaws in position
  • Baking can be adjusted to the millimeter
  • sits stably on the workbench
  • is not mobile
  • Clamping position is only conditionally adjustable

2. Which vice types are available?

The principle of the vice is the same for all types of vises: they clamp something. But when clamping there are small differences, For which type is good and in which category a model falls, you see here in our vise comparison 2018:

Parallel vise

Vise comparison 2018: vice

  • the classic vise
  • Baking is always parallel to each other
  • helps to hold workpieces evenly

Vise comparison 2018: 2018

  • Jaws are parallel only when closed
  • Jaws are connected by a kind of hinge
  • also called bottle vise
  • Baking drops off to the sides
  • withstands high heat
  • can be used as an anvil, as a mainstay intercepts the momentum
Pipe vise

Vise comparison 2018: 2018

  • clamps pipes from different sides
  • usually prints from 2 to 4 pages
  • good for pipes and fragile parts
Machine vice

Vise comparison 2018: vise

  • clamps power tools for power tools, e.g. for a milling machine or table drill
  • Also available as a variant for clamping several parts
Carpenter Vise

Vise comparison 2018: vise

  • flat vise jaws - gentle on wood
  • Vise jaws mostly made of wood
  • as carpenter vise i.d.R. integrated into the workbench or mounted on the side of the bench

Vise comparison 2018: 2018

A specialist for angles: the angle vise.

Of course, there are many more types and shapes of vices, but these are the most common, similar to the classic parallel vise. A special form is for example the so-called "Nähross": a vise for saddler on which the saddler sits and works leather.

There are still others Angled vices that hold together strips at a 90° angle and filigree precision mechanics vices, which are suitable, for example, for model making. In a vise test or comparison, they can only keep up to a certain extent with the classic models. Particularly strong are hydraulic vicesbut they are usually installed on larger machines - such as a milling machine.

3. Purchase advice for vices: You must pay attention to this

These are the criteria that make up a potential vice test winner and comparison winner:

3.1. Which works do you need it for?

Vise comparison 2018: vise

A machine vice is ideal for every bench drill.

Depending on what you process most frequently in your workshop, the type of vise is the cheapest. If you want to set many precise holes, then a machine vice makes the most sense. The Machine vice can be easily mounted on the working surface of a bench drill.

We have compared suitable bench drilling machines for you here:

  • for bench drill comparison

If, on the other hand, a metal sheet is hammered or a piece of wood is shredded alternately, then the classic parallel vice is ideal. It is big enough for thin as well as thick parts. Also: The parallel vise is safe and solid on the workbench.

Forged on the vise or more often bent sheet metal and iron, a forged vice is interesting for you. In a forged vice, the jaws are angled slightly downwards. So you can work on them better the metal with the forging hammer.

Vise comparison 2018: 2018

Evenly clamped, the tube remains round.

If you cut curtain rods or thin sheet metal pipes on the assembly line, then you need a vice that does not crush the pipe or push in on one side. Tube vices press all around on the tube, The hollow part sits firmly on the one hand in the vise, on the other hand it is not damaged.

If wood is your main material, then it pays to have your own carpenter's vice. Flat jaws do not make dents in the wood, Either vices of carpenters are embedded in the workbench or are mounted to the side.

AllrounderWho wants to equip his workshop, but is still unsure, which should resort to a parallel vise. This vise is good for many different uses.

3.2. material

Vise comparison 2018: 2018

An efficient team: parallel and carpenter vice.

A carpenter's vice with wooden jaws is best for carpentry work. But these Wooden jaws are too soft for sheet metal or blacksmith work, If hard materials are to be clamped, then a metal vice is the best choice.

3.3. Width & span

The maximum span limits how large the clamped workpieces may be at most: Particularly thick workpieces require particularly large spans.

Important size: the jaw width. It is relevant when the pressure is to be distributed very evenly on a workpiece, For example, if the jaws are too small when glued, they only apply pressure on one side and the parts are not properly glued afterwards. A good average width is about 100 mm. Other models are 120 to 150 mm.

3.4. Au cheek: protective, protective and clamping jaw

Vise comparison 2018: 2018

Protective jaws protect workpieces.

The material determines the choice of your jaws: Soft soft jaws are important for soft materials such as wood, Over the actual metal jaws can also be put on protective jaws. These can be either wood or plastic.

However, protective or protective jaws also reduce the gap between the jaws, because they are placed in front of it.

3.5. change jaw

When buying a vice, be sure to use interchangeable jaws. Replacement jaws can be bought for these if they have been used for years. Often deep indentations in the jaws lead to damage to the materials.

3.6. What matters

Magnetic accessories

Replaceable jaws are already very practical. But Magnetic replacement jaws are better, They no longer need to be screwed to the vice, but hold by magnet.

They are simply clicked or removed.

Vise comparison 2018: 2018

If you only have an improvised workbench, it is worth taking a look at the weight of the vice. The best vise does not help much when the table tilts with it to the side.

3.7. Turnable and tiltable?

The vice becomes flexible when it is standing on its own turntable. So you can subsequently change the angle of the clamped workpiece.

If the vice is also tiltable, then it can be work the top of a workpiece from the side, This is useful if, for example, you would like to drill into the workpiece with a hand drill. So you do not need to hold the drill over the vise, but can easily start from the side.

3.8. With anvil

Vise comparison 2018: vise

A small anvil plate is enough for many uses.

Even if there are forged grommets, the classic vise is also enough for small metal work. The Jaws of a parallel vice are usually made of steel and therefore keep much But some models even have their own steel plate, which acts as a small anvil.

4. Frequently asked questions about vices

4.1. When was the vice invented?

The first (parallel) vise, as we know it today, was used by the British in 1830. This was still completely made of cast iron and thus prone to material weaknesses and cracks. In today's models, usually only the base body made of cast iron and the jaws are made of steel (sources: the "vise wiki" by the manufacturer Heuer and Wikipedia).

4.2. How much does a vice weigh?

Small models, such as pipe or machine vices, weigh approximately between two and four kilograms. The larger forge and Parallel vices weigh between four and 15 kilograms.

4.3. How much power does a vice have?

Vise comparison 2018: vise

The power comes from the lever over the spindle in the jaws.

If a vice is needed, then power is needed. But how much is it possible with a vise? Since the so-called lever laws come to fruition with a vise, only presses a vise as strong as "levering in" power with a lever.

The vise flail is the lever to which you give your physical strength. This gives the force to the vise spindle. This is a power transmission as in a transmission, Through this transmission, your strength is strengthened.

Theoretically, this force could also be calculated, but then you would have to know very well with how much muscle power you push into the lever (converted to Newton meters). You can measure the force more comfortably and easily with a so-called spring balance.

unkaputtbar: So that you do not accidentally apply too much force to the vise spindle, the lever is shortened to a certain length. For greater leverage, you would need a longer lever.

4.4. How much does a quality vise cost?

Vise comparison 2018: vise

A vise of linen usually has interchangeable jaws.

Prices for quality vices start at 100 euros and upwards. These are very precise in the regulation of the jaws, In addition, they are mostly made of high quality and stainless steel. The brands and manufacturers Proxxon, Leinen, Röhm, EGA, Yost Vises and Brockhaus Heuer play among others in this league.

However, in DIY stores such as Obi, Bauhaus or Hornbach also good vices made of cast iron, which are much cheaper. There there are vices for about 30 to 50 euros.

Vibration test winner, who would have chosen institutions like Stiftung Warentest or "Selbst ist der Mann", you will not find in this area. However, you find yourself Hardly reliable vise tests on the Internet.

If that's still too expensive for you, you can also borrow a vice used in the hardware stores.

Other interesting vise manufacturers are also:

  • Berlan
  • Brothers Mannesmann
  • küpper
  • Matador
  • professional
  • bison
  • Zyliss

Similar sites

  • Jigsaw templates
  • Gutters for every roof and gutter type
  • Which workbench is the right one and how can I build it myself?
  • Tinker with wood
  • Clamping tools in the workshop
  • Baking Christmas cookies - cookies bake with kids
  • Wooden Christmas decorations: making Christmas decorations out of wood
  • Bake dog biscuits yourself
  • Workbench
  • angle
  • bird house
  • Bodenwischer
  • Rotary Hammer
  • Wood stove

Video Board: Fly Tying Vise Comparison