Weather station comparison 2018

Purchase advice for weather station comparison or test 2018

  • There are analogue and digital weather stations. Analog stations are the classics among the meteorological stations, whereas the digital models represent the current standard.
  • Digital weather stations are also easy to read for non-weather frogs, whereas reading the analog variants requires previous meteorological knowledge.
  • When installing a digital (radio) weather station, make sure there are as few obstacles as possible between the base and the outdoor sensors. Ideally, there should be visual contact between these two components.

Weather station comparison 2018: weather

"There is no wrong weather, only wrong clothes." This saying takes into account the fact that the German or Central European weather can be very changeable. If you do not want to be surprised by such a change of weather, you should either be prepared at all times, for example by wearing a rain jacket or carrying an umbrella, or you will be regularly informed about the weather and upcoming changes.

One way to do this Weather stations for home or garden, which can capture the local weather conditions usually very precisely. If you are enthusiastic about such a weather station, then you are exactly right in our weather station comparison 2018! Because our guide to the subject provides you with useful information about weather stations and tells you in the context of a purchase advice, what is important when purchasing a meteorological station.

1. Digital weather stations are standard

A weather station for home or for home and garden allows to determine the local weather. It will basically distinguish between two types of weather stations: The analog and the digital stations. We have compared the respective advantages and disadvantages of the devices for you:

Analog weather stationDigital weather station

Weather station comparison 2018: weather

Weather station comparison 2018: comparison

Analog weather stations are the classics among the meteorological stations. The analog models have in most cases:

  • a thermometer (measuring the temperature)
  • a barometer (measurement of barometric pressure changes) as well
  • a hygrometer (measurement of humidity).

If one can interpret the values ​​of these measurements, which are represented on scales, one obtains a weather forecast. Analog stations require prior knowledge for correct reading, which can be a real hurdle for laymen.

Digital weather stations consist of a base station incl. Power connection and external sensors or sensors (= "satellites"), which are connected via radio to the base station. Measured with:

  • a (radio) thermometer (measuring the temperature)
  • a barometer (measurement of barometric pressure changes) and
  • a hygrometer (measurement of humidity).

The measurements are carried out at intervals. These are closer to each other on expensive models (about 2.5 seconds) than in the case of favorable weather stations (about 45 seconds), which is why expensive devices usually measure more precisely.

does not consume any power / battery
easy installation
no fully automated measurements
needs experience to interpret the measurements
high measurement inaccuracies possible
fully automated measurements
no experience needed to interpret the measurements
if correctly installed, low measurement inaccuracy
consumes power / battery
Installation a bit more complicated
Conclusion: If you want to get your weather forecast very conveniently, then you should buy a digital weather station. On the other hand, if you have prior knowledge of meteorology, you can also use an analogue station.

3. Digital weather stations: pictograms simplify reading

Weather station comparison 2018: weather

The weather forecasts as a pictogram. As weather symbols often a sun, a cloud or a snowflake are used.

The previous table has made it clear: In order to be able to read analogue weather stations, the user needs meteorological previous knowledge. If these are not present, the various scales of the station are rather confusing and not meaningful.

For this reason, analogue weather stations are very rare these days, which also explains the popularity of digital devices: Digital weather stations are easy to use and can be read very easily, because the interpretation of the data done by a weather station with "weather forecast function" mostly themselves.

A weather station with prediction function often works with so-called pictograms. So small pictures, which are generally understandable: Sun stands for good weather with sunshine, a cloud with drops for rainy weather, etc.

With favorable weather stations, often only a weather forecast for the next 24 hours is possible. On the other hand, if the device can provide a weather forecast for several days, this must be explicitly stated in the product description of the device.

What does meteorology actually mean?

Meteorology deals with the "processes and laws in the atmosphere of the earth" (= atmosphere) (Source: Duden.de). The best known branches of meteorology are meteorology (= weather forecast) and climatology.

In addition to the user-friendly weather forecast function, the majority of digital radio weather stations also offer concrete data in the form of individual, local values ​​for:

  • the temperature (measured with a thermometer, often switchable between the units Celsius (=° C) and Fahrenheit (=° F)
  • the air pressure (measured with a barometer) and
  • the humidity (measured with a hygrometer).

Please note: Simple digital weather stations can do without the input of external data. This means that the data always relates only to the location of the device. This is different for models that receive weather data from an external source. Read more in the next section.

3.1. The best weather stations work with satellite support

Weather station comparison 2018: weather

A rain sensor measures the amount of rainfall. Rain is collected, the amount measured and this number extrapolated.

Particularly accurate forecasts allow weather stations that work not only with local but with regional data. But how do the stations get to this data? Very easily: The models work with satellite support!

This means that the weather station is supplied with the data of a weather satellite in the atmosphere at regular intervals. In this way, the local weather station delivers much more accurate data even for several days in advance. This applies, for example.

  • Rainfall
  • Storm and storm warnings
  • Great weather situation and much more.

The Advantages and disadvantages of satellite weather stations at a glance:

  • very accurate readings
  • large amount of data
  • Comparison with supraregional sources
  • quite expensive in purchase

4. Special features of digital weather stations: pollen forecast and smartphone connection

particularityexplanation
Weather station with pollen forecastWeather station with a pollen forecasting function also provides information about up to 14 different types of pollen in addition to the weather forecast. The forecast period is three days. The data is taken from the devices of external weather services.
Semiprofessional weather stationsA semi-professional weather station can do more than 'normal' weather stations. Above all, further measuring sensors are responsible for this:

  • For example. an anenometer (measurement of wind speed)
  • a pluviometer (measurement of precipitation) or else
  • Lightning detectors and much more
Weather stations with computer / smartphone connectionSome weather stations can also pass data to the home computer. To do this, the base station is connected to the computer via USB or WLAN.

A similar category includes weather stations that forward the data to a smartphone app.

If you are interested in such models, pay attention to name additions such as "USB", "WLAN" or "Smartphone App" when purchasing the meteorological station.

5. Tips for installing a digital weather station

Before you decide for your personal weather station test winner, you should not only take a look at the purchase criteria presented so far, but also consider a few other factors:

One of the most important technical features of a digital weather station is the range of the transmitter / receiver. This should ideally reach 100 meters or more. Because:

The higher the range of a weather station fails, the higher the likelihood that the base station has a good reception despite any obstacles. With a shorter range, even smaller or thin obstacles can cause poor reception.

5.2. Correct position of the base station and the outdoor sensors

The correct position of your weather station has a great influence on the measuring accuracy of the device. There are some things to keep in mind when it comes to positioning the base station as well as the outdoor sensors:

Weather station comparison 2018: 2018

To keep you out of the rain: weather stations are a great way to find out about the weather for the next few days. This will save you the occasional weather surprise.

Installation of the base station:

How good are weather apps?

Weather apps are a cheap alternative, but at best they are based on the data from metereological institutes and are thus less accurate than a weather station. The Stiftung Warentest has critically dealt with the topic of "weather apps" and found that the majority in terms of data protection is not convincing. You can read more about this topic here. A weather station test has not yet been carried out by the test institute.

  • Place the base station in a slightly elevated location, such as a coffee table or side table. Avoid the direct positioning of wireless weather stations next to electronic devices (eg television, wireless router), as the electromagnetic fields of these devices can interfere with the reception or reduce its range.
  • Avoid positioning next to or on heat sources (eg heating).
  • Make sure there is visual contact between the base station and the outdoor sensorso there are no obstacles in between. If no visual contact is possible, you should at least align the parts so that only one obstacle (= wall / tree / disc) lies between them.
  • Recommendation: Ideally, permanently attach the base station of your weather station to a fixed position. This is particularly easy if the model of choice is characterized by the possibility of wall mounting.

Installation of outdoor sensors:

Weather station comparison 2018: comparison

Such a professional weather station is rarely seen in local gardens.
  • Ideally, position the sensors of your weather station with the outdoor sensor in visual contact with the base station. If no visual contact is possible, the parts should be aligned so that only one obstacle (= wall / tree / disc) is in the way.
  • Choose a location for the sensors where the measurements can not be distorted by direct sunlight or other heat sources (heat accumulators on the house wall, etc.).
  • The location should be have good air circulation, so that air pressure, humidity and also the temperature can be measured easily.
  • Follow the manufacturer's instructions when mounting weather stations with a rain or anemometer. In the case of anemometers, mounting on the roof is generally recommended.

Particularly popular manufacturers of weather stations are TFA and Bresser. Here is an overview of the best-known brands:

  • Bresser
  • TFA Dostmann
  • HAMA
  • Techno Line
  • ADE
  • Excelvan
  • Netatmo
  • Oria
  • intenso
  • Levin
  • Mebus
  • Auriol

Similar sites

  • Sauna manufacturer: Overview
  • Lawn robots from different manufacturers compared
  • Outdoor surveillance camera: Reolink Argus 2 in test
  • Powerline adapter test: FRITZ! Powerline 1260E WLAN Set and FRITZ! DECT Repeater 100
  • Electric bicycle - e-bike and pedelec
  • Product test: LUPUSEC - XT1 Starter Pack (alarm system)
  • Vacuum robot test: Kärcher RoboCleaner RC 3 with app and navigation
  • underfloor heating
  • Vacuum robot test: Neato Botvac D7 ™ Connected
  • Surveillance Camera Test: Arlo Pro 2 and Security System
  • key Finder
  • Washing machine
  • Outdoor smartphone
  • Wireless BBQ Thermometer

Video Board: TOP 5: Best Home Weather Stations 2018